Violence and Prose

Books Like Blood Meridian: Dark, Lyrical, Unforgiving

Nine books that share Blood Meridian's mix of beauty and slaughter, from McCarthy's own Outer Dark to a western with jokes and a verse ballad of my own.

The closest books to Blood Meridian are Cormac McCarthy's own Outer Dark and The Road, John Williams's Butcher's Crossing, Oakley Hall's Warlock and Ian McGuire's The North Water. Each sets hard, beautiful prose against violence that the narrator will neither explain nor excuse. For fantasy, Gene Wolfe's The Book of the New Sun comes nearest, and Patrick deWitt's The Sisters Brothers is the lighter counterpoint. Nine books follow. One is my own and is marked as such.

What makes Blood Meridian different from other westerns?

Blood Meridian (1985) follows a boy known only as the Kid, who runs away from Tennessee and joins a gang of scalp hunters on the Texas and Mexico border in the middle of the nineteenth century. The gang is led by Captain Glanton and shadowed by Judge Holden, an enormous, pale, learned man who treats war as the natural state of mankind. Much of the history behind it is real.

Three things carry the book. The prose runs in long, biblical sentences with rare words, and it gives a sunset the same attention as a massacre. The narrator never judges: nobody is punished and nobody is saved. And the land seems indifferent to the people crossing it. Most books below share one or two of these. Very few share all three, so choose by the quality you want more of.

Which books are most like Blood Meridian?

1. The Road, by Cormac McCarthy

A father and his young son walk south through a burned America, pushing a cart of scavenged goods and hiding from starving people who hunt other people. McCarthy keeps the stripped landscape and the low, scriptural cadence, and he shortens the sentences. It suits readers who want his prose at a gentler heat. It differs from Blood Meridian in its centre, because here two people love each other and the whole book pushes to keep that alive.

2. Outer Dark, by Cormac McCarthy

McCarthy's second novel (1968) follows a brother and sister in a rural South of no fixed year. Rinthy bears her brother Culla's child, and Culla leaves the baby in the woods and tells her it died. She goes looking for it while three killers ride the same roads. Its prose is more ornate than The Road's, and its dread has no historical frame to hide behind. Its premise involves incest and the abandonment of an infant. It suits readers who want the gothic McCarthy at his most unforgiving. It differs in scale: a small country and a single wound.

3. Butcher's Crossing, by John Williams

Will Andrews, a young man who has left Harvard, goes to Kansas in the 1870s and joins a buffalo hunt led by a man named Miller into a hidden valley in Colorado. The hunt succeeds beyond reason and turns into slaughter for its own sake, and winter closes the way out. Williams, who also wrote Stoner, writes plain, careful sentences, and the book is quieter than McCarthy's. It suits readers who want the west seen through its killing, with a moral centre intact. It differs in prose: where McCarthy ornaments, Williams keeps still.

4. The North Water, by Ian McGuire

In 1859 Patrick Sumner, a former army surgeon, signs onto the whaler Volunteer, bound from Hull for the Arctic. Also aboard is Henry Drax, a harpooner who kills without conscience. The ice replaces the desert, and the book moves faster than McCarthy, with a thriller's pull. It suits readers who want an amoral killer and a landscape that does not care. Drax is simpler than Judge Holden, and the novel gives Sumner a conscience to measure him against.

5. Warlock, by Oakley Hall

The mining town of Warlock hires a gunman with a reputation, Clay Blaisedell, to keep order. Over a long novel the town finds it has swapped one danger for another. Hall's 1958 western is a novel of ideas, and it asks who gets to decide what law is. It suits readers who want the frontier as a moral argument. It differs because its violence is something a town chooses to buy.

6. Between Two Fires, by Christopher Buehlman

France, 1348. A knight named Thomas and a girl named Delphine cross a country emptied by plague while angels and demons take an active part in what happens. It is bloody and often beautiful, written with a chronicler's mix of piety and gore. It suits readers who want a killing road in a medieval hell. It differs from McCarthy because this world has a God and a devil who answer back. I list it in books like Dante's Inferno as well.

7. The Book of the New Sun, by Gene Wolfe

Four volumes, beginning with The Shadow of the Torturer (1980). Severian, a young apprentice in the guild of torturers, is cast out for an act of mercy to a prisoner and travels across Urth, a far-future Earth under a dying sun. Wolfe's prose is ornate, archaic and exact, and his narrator claims never to forget anything while leaving the reader to check what he says. It suits readers who want McCarthy's richness and moral coldness inside a fantasy. It demands rereading, and its cruelty is ritual where McCarthy's is elemental.

8. The Sisters Brothers, by Patrick deWitt

Eli and Charlie Sisters are hired killers riding from Oregon to San Francisco in the Gold Rush of 1851. Eli, who tells the story, is tired of killing and wonders about another life. The violence is real, but the voice is deadpan and funny. It suits readers who want a western with McCarthy's cruelty in a dose they can bear. It gives its killer a narrator who wants to be better, and it gets laughs.

9. The Curse I, by Alexander Gabriel ZoderoT (my own book)

Weigh this one with care. The Curse I is my own graphic ballad, and it is no western. It is a dark spiritual fantasy told in verse, dark prose and gothic full-page images. Drakko, a farmer's son, vows to lay down the sword after one last job, and the man he is sent to kill breaks the vow before it can be kept. What it shares with Blood Meridian is a violent world, language with a rhythm, and the pull of grief toward rage. What it does not share is McCarthy's refusal of meaning: its own page treats Drakko's descent as an initiation, with each loss a layer of the false self burning away. Choose it for the verse and the shadow. It is for mature readers, the ebook is $0.99, and its free prequel is The Last Whisper of the Orchard. For the pictorial side of this dread, see gothic graphic novels for adults.



What to Read First

Which of these should you read first?

If you have not read Blood Meridian itself, start there, and expect scalping, massacre and cruelty on nearly every page. After it, choose by what you wanted more of.

  • McCarthy's prose with a heart: The Road.
  • The darkest early McCarthy: Outer Dark.
  • The west seen through slaughter: Butcher's Crossing.
  • A killer on the ice: The North Water.
  • A town and its hired gun: Warlock.
  • A plague road in medieval France: Between Two Fires.
  • The same richness in fantasy: The Book of the New Sun.
  • The west with jokes: The Sisters Brothers.
  • Verse, shadow and a descent: The Curse I.

Is there fantasy like Blood Meridian?

Few fantasy writers match McCarthy's prose, and Wolfe is the clearest case. Grimdark is the label most often reached for after McCarthy, though it tends to bring more plot, more banter and a firmer sense of who is to blame. The guide to dark fantasy versus grimdark separates the two, and philosophical dark fantasy books lists seven that ask harder questions. For verse, Fantasy Novels in Verse collects the older poems.

Questions readers ask

What is the closest book to Blood Meridian?

In voice, McCarthy's own books are closest: Outer Dark at full darkness, The Road at a gentler heat. In setting and in the scale of its slaughter, John Williams's Butcher's Crossing comes nearest.

Is The Road like Blood Meridian?

In its stripped landscape and low, scriptural cadence, yes. It is shorter and plainer, and it is built around a father's love for his son, a centre that Blood Meridian does not have.

Is there a lighter book like Blood Meridian?

The Sisters Brothers by Patrick deWitt. Two hired killers ride from Oregon to San Francisco in the Gold Rush, and the narrator is tired of killing and often funny.

Is there fantasy like Blood Meridian?

Gene Wolfe's The Book of the New Sun matches its richness and moral coldness. From my own shelf, The Curse I shares a violent world and a lyrical voice, told as a graphic ballad in verse.

Is The Curse I like Blood Meridian?

It shares a violent world, a lyrical rhythm and the pull of grief toward rage. It does not share McCarthy's refusal of meaning, since its own page treats the hero's losses as an initiation, and it is a fantasy ballad, not a western.

The Inner Circle

Join the Circle

The next book is already taking shape in the dark.

Be the first to know about new releases, exclusive content, hardcover drops, and glimpses behind the veil of ZoderoT's worlds.

No spam. No noise. Only the signal that matters.