Villain Fiction

Fantasy Books With Villain Protagonists and Villain Origins

Eight books that give the villain the story: a monster, a witch, a brigand prince, a revenge plot, a fallen angel and a villain origin of my own.

The best fantasy books with villain protagonists are Gregory Maguire's Wicked, John Gardner's Grendel, Madeline Miller's Circe, Mark Lawrence's Prince of Thorns and Joe Abercrombie's Best Served Cold. Each one hands the story to someone the usual fantasy would call the enemy, and each asks you to follow that person closely. John Milton's Paradise Lost, Jacqueline Carey's Banewreaker and a graphic ballad of my own complete the list.

What makes a villain the protagonist of a fantasy novel?

A villain protagonist is a character the story asks you to follow from the inside, even when the story itself would call that character the enemy. Some books let the villain argue for his reasons at length. Others let the villain's acts do the talking and keep the reader outside the mind.

A story like this stands or falls on three things. The narrator matters most: a monster telling its own story feels nothing like the same monster seen across the hall. The book also has to let the villain be wrong, since a villain who is never mistaken becomes a sermon. And the book has to decide what happens to the people the villain hurts, and whether it looks at them at all.

Milton's Satan is the old example that most readers still argue over. He is the most vivid figure in Paradise Lost, and the poem gives him some of its most energetic lines. That is why the poem still belongs in any conversation about villains, even though it is not a novel.

Which fantasy books have a villain as the main character?

1. Grendel, by John Gardner

Gardner's Grendel tells the story of Beowulf from the monster's side. The creature lives in a cave near Heorot, the hall where the Danes feast and sing, and he watches them with a bitter and clever eye. He is not a mindless beast in this version. He thinks about meaning and about the gods, and he hates the poets who turn Hrothgar's men into heroes. It suits readers who like a philosophical villain with a dry, dark humour, and anyone who has wondered what the monster in an old poem would say if he could speak. The book is short, and the heroes appear only as they look from outside, which changes how the whole old poem reads.

2. Wicked, by Gregory Maguire

Maguire takes the Wicked Witch of the West from L. Frank Baum's The Wonderful Wizard of Oz and gives her a childhood, a school and a political life. Elphaba is born green, and the novel follows her through her schooling and into the politics of Oz, where who counts as good depends on who is telling the story. It suits readers who enjoy political fantasy and want a villain more complicated than a costume. The tone is wry and sad, and the book is long. Its villain is the figure the 1939 film made famous, so the reader meets her again as a person.

3. Prince of Thorns, by Mark Lawrence

The narrator of Prince of Thorns is Jorg Ancrath, a young prince who leads a band of brigands and stays ruthless throughout the book. Lawrence writes in a flat, cold first person, and the violence is frequent and unsparing. It suits readers who want a villain with little comfort in him and who can take a grim, brutal book. Readers who need a moral frame around the narrator will find little of one here. It is not for everyone, so sample it before you buy. The first volume opens The Broken Empire trilogy, which has two sequels.

4. Best Served Cold, by Joe Abercrombie

Best Served Cold is a revenge story set in the world of Abercrombie's First Law books. Its lead, Monza Murcatto, is a mercenary who works through the men who wronged her, and she is no hero by any ordinary measure. The book is brutal, often funny and patient about the planning and the cost of each act of revenge. It suits readers who want a lead with no heroic cover and a plot built on grudges. The humour sits right beside the violence, so the book rarely feels solemn, even at its darkest.

5. Circe, by Madeline Miller

Circe takes the sorceress of Homer's Odyssey, the woman who turns Odysseus's men into swine, and lets her tell her own life. The book begins with her childhood among the gods, follows her into exile on an island, and shows the people who pass through her life as she sees them. The old stories treat her as a danger to be outwitted. Miller treats her as the one telling the story. It suits readers who love myth and want a witch's account of her own power, slow and reflective, with the gods at the edges.

6. Paradise Lost, by John Milton

Paradise Lost is an English epic poem, not a novel, and it is the oldest book on this list. Satan is its most vivid figure, the one who gives many of its most energetic speeches, and Milton opens by stating that his aim is to justify the ways of God to men. Many readers have found that Satan's arguments are harder to dismiss than the poem seems to want. It suits readers who want the old argument over whether the villain has taken over the poem, and who can handle blank verse at a steady pace. It is slow in places, and the long speeches ask for patience.

7. Banewreaker, by Jacqueline Carey

Banewreaker is the first book of The Sundering, a Tolkien-like war between light and dark, told from the side of the dark. Carey gives the conflict the scale of an epic, and she asks what the familiar heroes look like from the other side of the sword. It suits readers who enjoy big epic fantasy and want a Tolkien-style war turned around. Readers who know The Lord of the Rings will recognise the shape of the war, and the pleasure is in seeing it from the other side. The scale asks for patience, and the book rewards readers who are willing to give it time.

8. Chronicles of Bubhutśātsu: Awakening, by Alexander Gabriel ZoderoT (my own book)

This one is my own, so read the description with that in mind. Chronicles of Bubhutśātsu: Awakening is a 263-page graphic ballad about a figure marked by cosmic prophecy from birth and shunned by fate, who grows up craving a greatness his beginnings could never hold. The book's own page says he is not a hero. He is the dreamer who crosses the line between ambition and darkness. The story is told in poetic narration with densely worked monochrome art, and it is the origin of one of the central threats in The Path of None. It suits readers who want a villain origin in verse. For the author's guide to the book, read Bubhutśātsu: How a Dreamer Becomes a Shadow.



Choosing Between Them

Where to start

If this is your first villain protagonist, start with Circe or Grendel. Both are quiet, and both let the villain's voice carry the whole book. Readers who want the hardest material should go to Prince of Thorns or Best Served Cold, and readers who want the older argument can begin with Paradise Lost.

  • A monster who thinks: Grendel.
  • A witch with a life of her own: Circe.
  • A green girl and a political Oz: Wicked.
  • A young prince with a band of brigands: Prince of Thorns.
  • A revenge plot with no hero in it: Best Served Cold.
  • A war told from the dark side: Banewreaker.
  • A poem whose devil is its most vivid figure: Paradise Lost.
  • A villain origin in verse: Chronicles of Bubhutśātsu: Awakening.

For the pictorial side of the same dread, gothic graphic novels for adults covers the houses, ruins and towns that act as the threat. If you want the same question asked in comics, the companion piece is Dark Fantasy Graphic Novel Series Worth Reading in Order.

Questions readers ask about villain protagonists

Which fantasy novel gives a famous villain her own story?

Gregory Maguire's Wicked does this with the Wicked Witch of the West from L. Frank Baum's book. Madeline Miller's Circe does it with the sorceress of Homer's Odyssey.

Is Paradise Lost a fantasy novel?

No. It is an English epic poem about the fall of Satan and the fall of the first humans. It is on this list because its villain is the most vivid figure in the poem, and readers have argued about that for centuries.

Which villain fantasy is the least brutal?

Circe and Grendel are the quietest books on the list, though neither is gentle. Prince of Thorns is the most violent, and Best Served Cold comes close.

Is Chronicles of Bubhutśātsu: Awakening a story with a villain as its main character?

Yes. The book's own page describes Bubhutśātsu as the dreamer who crosses the line between ambition and darkness. It is a 263-page graphic ballad.

The Inner Circle

Join the Circle

The next book is already taking shape in the dark.

Be the first to know about new releases, exclusive content, hardcover drops, and glimpses behind the veil of ZoderoT's worlds.

No spam. No noise. Only the signal that matters.