Worlds Without a Rulebook
Absurdist Fantasy Books: When the World Refuses to Make Sense
Eight books in which the rules are senseless, the authorities cannot be found and the world itself is the joke, with a note on how absurdism differs from parody.
The best absurdist fantasy books are Terry Pratchett's Discworld novels, Mervyn Peake's Gormenghast, Flann O'Brien's The Third Policeman and Jasper Fforde's The Eyre Affair, with Douglas Adams's The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy and Joseph Heller's Catch-22 as the reference points from science fiction and war. Absurdist fiction places people in a world that gives no reason for what happens to them and has them carry on anyway. The list below covers eight books, from Kafka's castle to a village that believes a lie, and one of them is my own, placed at the edge.
What Is Absurdist Fantasy?
Absurdism as an idea belongs to the twentieth century. Albert Camus used the word for the clash between a person who wants meaning and a universe that supplies none, and playwrights such as Samuel Beckett put that clash on stage. In fiction it usually appears as a rule with no purpose, an authority nobody can find or a logic that is perfectly consistent and perfectly mad. Fantasy gives this kind of writer an advantage, because the author can build the madness into the furniture: a castle, a bureaucracy, a policeman's theory of bicycles.
How Is Absurdism Different From Parody and Satire?
Parody imitates a specific work or form and exaggerates it, so it needs a target the reader already knows. Satire aims at real abuses, such as bad rulers, empty institutions and fashionable nonsense. Nonsense, the tradition of Lewis Carroll, plays with language and logic for the pleasure of it. Absurdism asks what a person does in a world without answers, and the humour is often what it costs to ask.
Most books below mix two or three of these. A useful test is to ask whether the world could be fixed. In a satire a better ruler or a sharper clerk could set things right. In an absurdist book nothing in the world is waiting to be fixed, because the senselessness is the setting. By that test Pratchett is mostly satire and Kafka is purely absurd, with Heller and O'Brien somewhere between.
Which Absurdist Fantasy Books Should You Read?
Franz Kafka: The Castle
K. arrives in a village to take up a post as land surveyor for the castle that overlooks it. The castle's officials never admit him and never send him away, and he spends the book trying to reach anyone who can settle his status. Kafka left the novel unfinished, and it was published after his death, in 1926. Nothing magical happens, yet the place runs on rules with no author, which is why fantasy readers keep claiming it. It differs from everything else here by never being funny in a way that lets you relax.
Joseph Heller: Catch-22
This 1961 novel follows Yossarian, a bombardier in the Second World War, on a Mediterranean island. He wants to stop flying missions. The rule he runs into says that a man can be grounded for madness only if he asks, and asking proves he is sane enough to keep flying. Meanwhile his colonel raises the number of required missions each time the men get close to the total. There is no fantasy in it. I include it because it is the model for a rule enforced with a straight face, and several books on this list use the same move.
Douglas Adams: The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy
Arthur Dent's house is due for demolition to make way for a bypass, and later the same day the Vogons demolish the Earth to make way for a hyperspace bypass. Ford Prefect, a researcher for the Guide, takes him along. It is science fiction, and it is the reference point for comic absurdity in speculative writing: a universe run by bureaucracy at every scale, and a supercomputer that offers 42 as the answer to the ultimate question of life, the universe and everything. It began as a radio series in 1978. It suits readers who want absurdity as a run of fast jokes. It differs from the fantasy on this list by never pretending the cosmos has a reason.
Terry Pratchett: Discworld
The Disc rides on the backs of four elephants who stand on a giant turtle, and it is the setting for dozens of novels. In The Colour of Magic (1983), a failed wizard named Rincewind is hired to guide Twoflower, the Disc's first tourist, around the city of Ankh-Morpork, with a travelling chest on many small legs, the Luggage, following them. Small Gods (1992) strands the god Om in the body of a tortoise with a single believer, the novice Brutha, and it is the book I would start with, since The Colour of Magic is the loosest of the series, a string of episodes that parodies fantasy habits.
Discworld is the warmest form of absurdity on this list, and I would argue that it is satire more than absurdism, because its world follows consistent rules and a character with sense can usually set a thing right. It suits readers who want to laugh at institutions. For the books where it turns angry, see the guide to funny grimdark fantasy books.
Mervyn Peake: Gormenghast
Titus Groan (1946) opens a trilogy that begins in Gormenghast, a vast decaying castle where the Groan family lives under a calendar of rituals whose purposes nobody remembers. Steerpike, a kitchen boy, schemes his way up through the household. The trilogy continues with Gormenghast and Titus Alone. There is no magic and very few easy jokes, and it still shelves with fantasy because in the first two books the castle is the whole world. The absurdity is ceremonial, and the prose is thick and slow. It differs from Pratchett by never winking.
Flann O'Brien: The Third Policeman
Written in the late 1930s, the novel was not published until 1967, after the author's death. Its narrator, who is never named, takes part in a murder for money and then finds himself in a police station run by Sergeant Pluck and Policeman MacCruiskeen, who explain a theory that people who ride bicycles exchange atoms with them until each is partly the other. A made-up scholar named de Selby is cited in elaborate footnotes. The humour comes from the logic, which is rigorous, and the book is darker than its jokes suggest. It suits readers who enjoy a puzzle with a drop beneath it. It differs from Adams in how little comfort it allows.
Jasper Fforde: The Eyre Affair
Set in an alternative 1985, in which the Crimean War still drags on and literature is a matter for the police, this novel follows Thursday Next, a literary detective. When a villain starts kidnapping characters out of manuscripts, Thursday follows the trail into the pages of Jane Eyre. It was published in 2001 and begins a series. The absurdity here is a game with rules that Fforde explains, so a reader is never lost. It differs from Kafka and O'Brien by wanting you to have fun all the way through.
Alexander Gabriel ZoderoT: Monday 'n' Mayhem (my own book)
I wrote Monday 'n' Mayhem, so weigh my placement of it accordingly, and I put it last because it belongs at the edge of this list. Its page calls it a satirical grimdark fantasy, and what is absurd in it is a story. The conman Mišo Kanis turns a murder born of a tavern brawl into a legend, and the legend drags the village of Mrkotín into a war against made-up enemies and absent gods.
It comes nearest to Heller in its ending. The page says nobody learns anything, that Mišo finishes about as capable as he began and that the point is survival, with no transformation. The machinery runs, and the people inside it get through. That makes it satire of belief more than a world that has lost its sense, and you should read it for that. It runs to 284 pages, and the free sample pages show the voice before you spend $0.99 on the ebook.
Where to Begin
Which Absurdist Fantasy Should You Read First?
- The easiest way in: Small Gods by Pratchett.
- The fastest jokes: The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy by Adams.
- A rule that eats its own exceptions: Catch-22 by Heller.
- A castle you cannot leave: Gormenghast by Peake.
- A logic puzzle with a trapdoor: The Third Policeman by O'Brien.
- Books about books: The Eyre Affair by Fforde.
- The ancestor of the form: The Castle by Kafka.
- A lie that becomes a war: Monday 'n' Mayhem.
Why Does Absurdism Work So Well in Fantasy?
The author of a fantasy world writes its laws, and an absurdist writes bad ones on purpose. A realistic novel needs a plausible reason for a ridiculous bureaucracy. A fantasy novel can simply have one, complete with its own gods, ranks and forms. That freedom is also why comic and grim fantasy borrow from the same shelf: the guide to dark fantasy and grimdark explains the labels, and the one on funny grimdark fantasy shows where a senseless rule starts killing people.
Readers who want the crew and the con more than the world can try fantasy books about con artists and thieves, and those who want companionship against bad odds will like books like Kings of the Wyld. For the tabletop version of the same chaos there is the guide to fantasy books that feel like a Dungeons and Dragons campaign. My own shelf is on the books page.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is absurdist fantasy?
Fantasy in which the world itself makes no sense: rules with no purpose, authorities nobody can find or a logic that is consistent and mad. Examples include Gormenghast, The Eyre Affair and parts of Discworld.
Is Discworld absurdist?
In part. Discworld is mostly satire and parody, because its world follows consistent rules and a sensible character can usually put things right. Its absurd premises, such as a flat world carried by four elephants on a turtle, give it the flavour.
What is the difference between absurdist fiction and parody?
Parody imitates a particular work or genre in order to mock it, while absurdist fiction places people in a world without sense and asks how they live there. Many books, including Discworld, combine the two.
Where should I start with absurdist fantasy?
Small Gods by Terry Pratchett is the easiest entry, The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy gives the fastest jokes and The Third Policeman is the deep end.
Is Monday 'n' Mayhem absurdist?
It is closer to satire. Its page calls it a satirical grimdark fantasy, and the absurd element is a story that grows into a war against made-up enemies.
The Inner Circle
Join the Circle
The next book is already taking shape in the dark.
Be the first to know about new releases, exclusive content, hardcover drops, and glimpses behind the veil of ZoderoT's worlds.
No spam. No noise. Only the signal that matters.