Grimdark With a Sense of Humour
Funny Grimdark Fantasy Books: Dark Worlds That Still Make You Laugh
Eight authors whose worlds are cruel, and where somebody keeps joking anyway, sorted by the kind of laughter each one offers.
The funniest grimdark fantasy comes from Joe Abercrombie, Scott Lynch, Christopher Buehlman, Jonathan French, K. J. Parker, Terry Pratchett and Nicholas Eames. Their worlds are violent and unfair, and each author finds a different laugh inside them: bitter, quick-witted, filthy, deadpan, satirical or warm. The list below names the book to read from each author and says what its humour is like. One entry is my own and is marked as such.
What Is Funny Grimdark Fantasy?
Grimdark fantasy puts its characters in a world of compromised rulers, expensive victories and good intentions that go unrewarded. Funny grimdark keeps all of that and lets the characters crack jokes anyway. The laughter is gallows humour, a way of surviving a siege, a torturer's commute or a bad plan. It is rarely slapstick.
Humour in this corner of fantasy comes in about three flavours. One is the bitter voice inside a single head. Another is satire pointed at armies, churches and city councils. The third is the banter of companions who like each other more than they admit. The guide to the difference between dark fantasy and grimdark makes the same point from the genre side: a joke does not stop a book from being grimdark, because the label depends on what the story does to its heroes.
Which Funny Grimdark Fantasy Books Should You Read?
Joe Abercrombie: The Blade Itself and Best Served Cold
Abercrombie is the name most readers mean by grimdark, and he is very funny. The Blade Itself opens The First Law with Sand dan Glokta, a crippled torturer whose bitter commentary on his own body and his own work is gallows humour at its sharpest. The jokes work because the cruelty around them is real. Best Served Cold is a revenge novel in the same world, about a mercenary commander left for dead by her employer, and its laughs are blacker still. It suits readers who want a joke that hurts a little. It differs from everything below in how little softness it allows.
Scott Lynch: The Lies of Locke Lamora
Locke Lamora is a thief and con artist in the canal city of Camorr, and his crew, the Gentleman Bastards, plan swindles with the care of a stage company. The humour lives in quick insults, elaborate lies and friends who tease each other while planning a robbery. Then the book turns savage, and the earlier laughter makes the damage hurt more. It suits readers who like caper plots and loyal companions. It differs from Abercrombie because the jokes come first and the grimness arrives later.
Christopher Buehlman: The Blacktongue Thief
Kinch Na Shannack is a thief who owes the Takers' Guild a large debt, and he tells his own story in a wry, foul-mouthed and oddly lyrical voice. He falls in with Galva, a giant warrior, on a road full of war and monsters. Buehlman also writes horror, and the dread under the jokes shows. It suits readers who want the humour carried by one narrator's voice. The laugh arrives in the telling more than in the plot.
Jonathan French: The Grey Bastards
The Grey Bastards follows half-orc outcasts who ride giant hogs and guard a hostile frontier. It is a biker-gang story in a fantasy world, and the humour is crude, loud and affectionate, with insults standing in for love. The violence is graphic and the language coarse, so check content notes first. It suits readers who want brotherhood with a raw edge. It differs from Lynch by trading wit for swagger.
K. J. Parker: Sixteen Ways to Defend a Walled City
Parker's narrator is an engineer who ends up responsible for defending a city against a besieging army that outnumbers it. His voice is dry, evasive and deadpan, and the comedy comes from logistics, bureaucracy and a man who talks his way out of everything. The book is low on magic and high on argument. It suits readers who prefer wit to swordplay. It differs from the rest of the list in how quiet its jokes are.
Terry Pratchett: Night Watch and Small Gods
Discworld is comic fantasy and not grimdark, yet two of its books go where grimdark readers go. In Night Watch, Commander Sam Vimes is thrown back in time into the Ankh-Morpork of his own youth, in the middle of a street uprising. In Small Gods, a god is stuck in the body of a tortoise with a single believer, a novice named Brutha, while the church built in his name turns to persecution. The satire is angry under the jokes, and the target is power. It suits readers who want to laugh at institutions. The violence is present but less graphic than in Abercrombie.
Nicholas Eames: Kings of the Wyld
Clay Cooper is a middle-aged former mercenary pulled back into the life when an old bandmate asks him to reunite their company and rescue his daughter from a besieged city. In Eames's world, mercenary bands tour and fight like rock groups, with fans, rivalries and bad knees. The humour is affectionate and rowdy, and this is the lightest book on the list. It has fights and losses, but its tone is warm. It suits readers who want friendship and ageing heroes more than despair, and it is also the first stop in the sibling guide to fantasy books that feel like a Dungeons and Dragons campaign.
Alexander Gabriel ZoderoT: Monday 'n' Mayhem (my own book)
I wrote Monday 'n' Mayhem, the first book of the Tales of the Damned Dice, so weigh my placement of it accordingly. It is a 284-page satirical grimdark novel about four men and a lie that grows too big. Mišo Kanis, conman, merchant and accidental prophet, has to turn a murder born of a tavern brawl into legend. His crew includes a four-and-a-half-foot bare-knuckle champion and a self-styled ranger whose stew is a crime. The humour is performance: invented sermons, bluff and bad decisions in a village called Mrkotín that is not a pleasant place. The book's own page says nobody learns anything, which keeps the comedy bleak.
Next to the established names above it is the unknown quantity, so read the sample pages before spending $0.99 on the ebook. It suits readers who enjoy a con artist at the centre, as in Lynch, and a world that stays ugly, as in Abercrombie.
Which Funny Grimdark Book Should You Start With?
- The bitterest laugh: The Blade Itself by Abercrombie.
- Banter and a heist: The Lies of Locke Lamora by Lynch.
- A narrator you will quote: The Blacktongue Thief by Buehlman.
- Crude brotherhood: The Grey Bastards by French.
- Wit without swordplay: Sixteen Ways to Defend a Walled City by Parker.
- Satire of power: Night Watch by Pratchett.
- Warmth between fights: Kings of the Wyld by Eames.
- A con that grows into a war, in under 300 pages: Monday 'n' Mayhem.
Can Grimdark Stay Funny Without Losing Its Weight?
It can, when the joke has a cost. Abercrombie's jokes sit beside maimings, Lynch's beside betrayal, Pratchett's beside a city in revolt. None of these books pretends that a laugh cancels a loss. The humour shows what people use to bear the damage, which is also why a funny grimdark novel can end up bleaker than a straight one: the reader has been laughing with characters who then pay.
Readers who want the serious end of the same territory can try philosophical dark fantasy books, and those who want it drawn can look at the best dark fantasy comics and graphic novels for adults. My darker spiritual books live in a separate series, and where to start with The Path of None explains how they are ordered. The full shelf is on the books page.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the funniest grimdark fantasy book?
There is no single winner, because the humour differs. Abercrombie's The Blade Itself has the bitterest voice, Pratchett's Night Watch the sharpest satire, and Eames's Kings of the Wyld the warmest laughs.
Is Terry Pratchett grimdark?
Not as a series. Discworld is comic fantasy, but Night Watch and Small Gods deal with revolution, persecution and the abuse of power, which is why grimdark readers often enjoy them.
Is Joe Abercrombie funny?
Yes. His humour is dark and sardonic, and it comes mostly from the inner voices of characters such as Sand dan Glokta, a crippled torturer in The Blade Itself.
Where should I start with funny grimdark fantasy?
Start with The Lies of Locke Lamora for banter, The Blade Itself for bitterness, or Kings of the Wyld for the lightest tone. The list above matches each book to a kind of humour.
Is Monday 'n' Mayhem like Joe Abercrombie?
Its page names The First Law trilogy, Kings of the Wyld and The Blacktongue Thief among the books it is aimed at readers of. At 284 pages it is shorter than Abercrombie's novels, and it builds its humour on a con and four companions in a single village. Read the sample pages to judge the voice.
The Inner Circle
Join the Circle
The next book is already taking shape in the dark.
Be the first to know about new releases, exclusive content, hardcover drops, and glimpses behind the veil of ZoderoT's worlds.
No spam. No noise. Only the signal that matters.